Quality assurance in forensic serology combines competent personnel, fit-for-purpose methods, suitable controls, traceable records and review. ISO/IEC 17025:2017 is a widely used laboratory-competence framework, while discipline-specific standards and local requirements define additional obligations. Accreditation applies to a stated scope; it does not guarantee that every result is correct.
Method validation, reagent acceptance, routine quality control and proficiency testing answer different questions. Use them together to identify problems and assess their impact. Neither an accreditation certificate nor a successful proficiency exercise replaces the evidence needed to interpret an individual case result.
An error in serological testing can misdirect sampling, reporting or an investigation. Quality assurance makes the basis of the result examinable: what was tested, which method and reagent were used, whether acceptance criteria were met and how the interpretation was reviewed. Hospital diagnostics also require quality control; forensic reliability should not be explained by dismissing clinical standards.
ISO/IEC 17025:2017 addresses competence, impartiality and consistent laboratory operation. Its requirements concern personnel, resources, processes and management systems, among other matters. The laboratory must implement requirements relevant to its activities rather than simply reproduce a generic checklist.
Check the accrediting body’s directory and the laboratory’s current scope. A certificate may cover some methods or locations without covering every forensic activity undertaken by the organisation. Accreditation, practitioner certification and membership of a professional association are different forms of recognition.
Routine controls test defined parts of the analytical system. Reagent acceptance checks suitability before use, while proficiency exercises examine performance on a specified task. Case review and nonconforming-work procedures connect these checks to reporting, including consideration of earlier results when a problem is discovered.
By the end of this topic you will be able to:
- Describe the current ISO/IEC 17025 framework without treating its older two-part structure as the 2017 organisation.
- Distinguish method validation, verification, reagent acceptance and routine controls.
- Explain how a failed control triggers a hold and a documented assessment of affected work.
- Distinguish external provision of proficiency samples from covert blinding of the exercise.
- Describe proportionate contamination prevention and jurisdiction-specific accreditation requirements.
Related reading: Order of Testing and DNA Preservation; Serology Evidence in Court: Interpretation and Testimony.
- ISO/IEC 17025
- ISO/IEC 17025:2017 specifies general requirements for the competence, impartiality and consistent operation of testing and calibration laboratories. It provides a framework for controlled work; accreditation against it concerns a defined scope and does not certify that every case conclusion is correct.
- Accreditation
- Accreditation is independent recognition of competence to perform specified activities against defined requirements. A laboratory’s current scope, methods and locations matter; accreditation is distinct from personal certification and does not automatically cover every service offered by the organisation.
- Positive control
- A positive control contains material expected to produce a defined response and checks relevant parts of a test system. An unexpected result requires assessment under predetermined acceptance criteria; affected casework must be held rather than reported as an ordinary negative result.
- Negative control
- A negative control is expected not to produce the target response and helps detect contamination, nonspecific reactions or other problems. Reagent blanks, substrate controls and known-negative samples test different sources of error; an unexpected signal requires investigation rather than an assumed diagnosis.
- Proficiency test
- A proficiency test evaluates participant performance on a defined task using samples or information for which expected findings can be assessed. Exercises can be internal or externally provided, declared or covert; external provision alone does not mean the analyst is unaware of being tested.
- OSAC
- The Organization of Scientific Area Committees for Forensic Science, administered by NIST, supports forensic standards development and implementation and maintains a registry. It works with standards developing organisations; registry inclusion is distinct from laboratory accreditation, legal admissibility or a universal mandate.
ISO/IEC 17025 as a Framework for Forensic Serology
The 2017 edition organises requirements into general, structural, resource, process and management-system categories. The older management-versus-technical division is a useful historical summary, not the current clause structure. For practical review, follow the edition and supplementary requirements applicable to the laboratory’s accredited scope.
Serological validation examines whether a method supports its stated purpose, including sensitivity, specificity, interference, reproducibility and appropriate interpretation criteria. ANSI/ASB Standard 077 addresses developmental and internal validation of forensic serological methods. Do not equate a presumptive blood response with unique identification or assume that a manufacturer’s study covers every laboratory adaptation.
Validation and verification are related but different from routine reagent acceptance. A new lot usually needs documented suitability checks under the laboratory’s procedure, not a complete repeat of developmental validation. Significant method changes require an assessment of which additional studies are necessary before implementation.
In the United States, OSAC promotes implementation of standards, including documents published by standards developing organisations. England and Wales have a statutory forensic code with activity-specific requirements. Other jurisdictions use their own accreditation and quality arrangements. Determine the applicable scope and current document rather than presenting one framework as universally mandatory.
Reagent Validation and Shelf-Life Controls
Reagent suitability depends on the particular formulation, lot, storage and period of use. Document receipt and acceptance against appropriate known materials and defined criteria. Comparison with an existing lot can help, but the previous lot is not an infallible reference and a full paired comparison is not universal for every reagent.
- Check the labelled expiry and any shorter laboratory-assigned or in-use period. Do not assume a reagent remains suitable because it has been stored correctly.
- Follow the product’s specified storage conditions and assess any excursion. Some tests are stored at room temperature; refrigeration is not a universal requirement.
- Document acceptance of new lots using suitable positives, negatives and other challenges required by the procedure.
- Record preparation or opening dates where relevant and maintain traceability between case samples and the reagent lots used.
A reagent failure uncovered in retrospect, after casework results have been reported, is a significant quality event. The laboratory must assess whether all results produced while the compromised reagent was in use are affected, and may need to re-test samples if they are still available.
Positive and Negative Controls in Casework
Controls are the mechanism by which an analyst confirms that the test system worked on the day the casework was run. A positive control is a sample that should give a positive result. If it does not, something is wrong with the system: the reagent may have degraded, the equipment may have malfunctioned, or the analyst may have made an error.
A reagent blank examines the reagents and handling steps it experiences. A substrate control and a known-negative biological material address different possible interference. An unexpected response can arise from contamination, nonspecific chemistry, handling or another failure; its cause is not established merely by observing it.
Control type, frequency and placement follow the validated method and applicable quality requirements. An internal cassette control does not replace every external or extraction control. If acceptance criteria fail, hold the affected results, define the scope of the problem and investigate before releasing conclusions.
Proficiency Testing and Inter-Laboratory Comparisons
Routine controls assess defined aspects of a run. A proficiency exercise assesses performance on the selected tasks and samples. The analyst may know that an external exercise is a test while remaining unaware of the expected answer. Covert introduction as ordinary casework is a separate level of blinding, and no exercise removes every source of bias.
Scroll horizontally if needed to see the full table.
Select an appropriate proficiency provider and exercise for the laboratory’s activities; accreditation bodies publish provider information. Investigate unsatisfactory or unexpected performance, assess affected casework and document corrective action and its effectiveness. Suspension or restriction of work depends on the findings and applicable procedure rather than an automatic worldwide response.
Contamination Prevention in Serology
Serology laboratories handle biological material, and the main contamination risk in a pre-DNA context is cross-transfer of bloodstains between samples. In a DNA-typing context, the contamination risk expands to include analyst DNA, which is both extremely sensitive and, if an analyst's profile is not in the exclusion database, potentially interpretable as evidence.
- Separate pre-amplification work from amplified DNA and control movement of materials and personnel. Assess other sample-to-sample transfer risks during collection, cutting and testing.
- Use suitable protective equipment and clean working practices; change gloves between items and whenever contamination is suspected. PPE does not replace cleaning or controlled handling.
- Use staff or scene-personnel elimination profiles where authorised and relevant, with appropriate consent, legal basis, access controls and interpretation. Database coverage is not universally complete or compulsory.
- Use suitable consumables and documented cleaning or decontamination procedures for reusable equipment. Human-DNA-risk manufacturing standards do not guarantee sterility or absence of every biological analyte.
Record who accessed relevant areas and how evidence was handled. Where elimination comparisons are authorised and available, they can help investigate a detected profile. The absence of a profile from an elimination database does not make it evidential, and a database match does not by itself identify the exact contamination event.
Accreditation Coverage Across Jurisdictions
In the United States, accreditation requirements depend on the activity, jurisdiction and relevant programme; ANAB is one forensic accreditor. ASCLD/LAB merged into ANAB in 2016 and should not be presented as a separate current alternative. Check the provider’s actual certificate and scope.
In England and Wales, the Forensic Science Regulator’s statutory Code of Practice version 2 came into force on 2 October 2025. Requirements depend on the forensic science activity and the code’s specified scope. It is inaccurate to say that every provider must hold ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation for every forensic activity, or to extend this framework automatically to all UK jurisdictions.
In India, NABL provides laboratory accreditation, while Australia’s NATA operates its own accreditation arrangements. Canada and other countries have further systems and requirements. Verify the individual laboratory’s current scope rather than asserting nationwide coverage or ranking countries without current data.