Skip to content

Side Determination and Fragment Identification

How an osteologist tells a left clavicle from a right, a rib fragment from a long-bone shaft, a juvenile vs adult fragment, and a human vs non-human bone (the classic forensic question 'is this human?'). The cortical-thickness, plexiform-bone and osteon-density criteria, the Owsley-Mann fragment ID protocols, and the radiographic and histological backstops.

By Reviewed by Sourabh

Last updated:

Side determination assigns a paired skeletal element to left or right using preserved anatomical landmarks. Fragment identification considers articular form, attachment sites, cross-sectional structure and other features together. The value of each feature depends on what survives and the available comparative material.

Element and side identification support inventory and commingling assessment, but a fragment may remain indeterminate. MNI can also use unpaired elements, age incompatibility and other duplication evidence; complete siding is not a prerequisite for every minimum count.

Initial examination assesses whether material is bone, whether it is human and what anatomy is preserved. Scene context and appropriate comparative or laboratory evidence contribute. An uncertain fragment need not be forced to element or side before all further work can begin.

Side determination is the process of assigning a skeletal element to the left or right side of the body. For complete, well-preserved bones the task is straightforward; the challenge arises with fragmented, degraded, or partially preserved specimens where the diagnostic features are damaged, worn, or missing.

Paired limb and girdle bones and ribs can often be sided using preserved landmarks. Vertebrae are unpaired midline elements, although an isolated neural-arch portion may be assigned to one side. Fragmentation, variation or damage can prevent a reliable side assignment.

Fragment identification, in its broader sense, is the assignment of a piece of bone to a specific skeletal element (rib? long-bone shaft? vertebral arch?) and to a specific anatomical region within that element. This matters for two distinct reasons.

Inventory identifies what is represented and which analyses may be possible. A long-bone fragment can be informative, but not every shaft supports stature estimation. Rib-shaft histology can contribute to age estimation using an appropriate method, so ribs are not categorically without age information.

The question "is this human?" is perhaps the most frequent forensic anthropology consultation in the world. Police, investigators, and members of the public regularly submit fragments recovered from fields, rivers, construction sites, and animal dens for professional assessment.

Non-human remains may be submitted for assessment. Their proportion depends on the service and referral context; no universal majority or laboratory workflow follows from an unspecified survey or historical attribution.

This topic covers anatomical landmarks for siding paired bones, assessment of fragmented elements, comparative tissue architecture and appropriate follow-up when human versus non-human origin remains uncertain. It distinguishes useful morphological clues from features that uniquely establish identity.

By the end of this topic you will be able to:

  • Identify the asymmetric morphological landmarks used to side the eight most forensically significant skeletal elements, including the clavicle, femur, os coxae, and rib.
  • Use preserved landmarks and comparative anatomy to assess element and region while stating when a fragment remains indeterminate.
  • Distinguish human from non-human bone using macroscopic criteria including cortical thickness ratios, plexiform bone, and articular surface morphology.
  • Interpret thin-section histological features, osteon shape, cement line character, and population density, to discriminate human from deer, bovid, pig, and avian bone.
  • Explain when radiographic assessment and DNA species confirmation are warranted as backstops when macroscopic and histological assessment is inconclusive.

Side Determination: The Eight Most Forensically Significant Elements

For any paired skeletal element, side determination relies on the identification of asymmetric morphological features, features that are anatomically different on the left and right even though the two bones are mirror images in outline. These features are consistent across populations and sexes, though their magnitude may vary with body size and activity level.

The clavicle’s enlarged medial end articulates with the sternum; its flatter lateral end articulates with the acromion. In superior view, the medial two-thirds curve convexly anteriorly and the lateral third is concave anteriorly. Use these relationships with inferior landmarks rather than ranking it as universally the easiest bone to side.

The costal impression or tuberosity lies inferiorly near the medial end for the costoclavicular ligament. The conoid tubercle is posteroinferior near the lateral end, with the trapezoid line extending laterally. The subclavian groove lies on the inferior shaft. A fragment must preserve enough relationships to establish orientation; one isolated rough area does not guarantee side.

Superior and inferior views of the same left clavicle. Illustrative anatomy. A clavicle fragment must preserve enough relationships to support siding; a single rough area is not always sufficient.

Do not infer clavicular side from a presumed larger right articular facet or handedness. Siding uses the preserved anatomical relationships; individual asymmetry does not provide a consistent right-versus-left size rule.

The humerus: the head is directed posteromedially and superiorly. The capitulum (lateral articular surface of the distal humerus) faces anteriorly and laterally. The olecranon fossa (the posterior recess that accommodates the olecranon at full extension) faces posteriorly.

The intertubercular groove is anterior, between the greater tubercle laterally and lesser tubercle medially. For a posterior view, orient the humeral head superiorly and medially with the olecranon fossa facing the observer. In that specified view, a capitulum on the observer’s right belongs to a right humerus; reverse the viewer-relative rule for an anterior view.

The femur: the head is directed medially, superiorly, and slightly anteriorly. The linea aspera (the posterior crest of the femoral shaft) runs along the posterior surface. The greater trochanter is lateral, the lesser trochanter is posteromedial. The popliteal surface (the flat triangular area at the posterior distal shaft) opens posteriorly.

Posterior views of a left humerus and left femur. Illustrative anatomical orientation. Siding uses a combination of preserved relationships rather than the viewer’s right or left.

Orient the femur with the head superior and medial, linea aspera posterior and patellar surface anterior. In posterior view with the linea aspera facing the observer, a head on the observer’s left indicates a right femur. Do not substitute a condylar-length impression for these combined landmarks.

Orient the hip bone with the iliac crest superior, acetabulum lateral and pubic symphyseal surface anteromedial. The greater sciatic notch lies posterior to the acetabulum. Match those directions to the anatomical side; a viewer-relative right/left shortcut requires a specified view.

The scapula: the glenoid fossa (the shallow socket for the humeral head) faces laterally and slightly anteriorly. The coracoid process hooks anteriorly from the superior border. The spine of the scapula runs posteriorly and rises to the acromion, which projects anterolaterally.

A left scapula in posterior view and left hip bone in lateral view. Illustrative anatomy. Orientation must be established before assigning a side to a fragment.

The concave subscapular fossa is on the anterior costal surface. Posteriorly, the supraspinous fossa lies above the spine and the broad infraspinous fossa below it. Orient the spine posteriorly, inferior angle inferiorly and glenoid laterally; an isolated coracoid direction without a specified view is not a reliable shortcut.

The radius: the radial head (proximal) is a disc that articulates with the capitulum of the humerus. The bicipital tuberosity (for the biceps brachii tendon insertion) is on the medial (ulnar) side of the proximal shaft. The styloid process of the distal radius is on the lateral (thumb) side.

In anatomical position the elbow is extended and the forearm supinated, with the palm anterior. The radial tuberosity is anteromedial, not posterior, and the distal styloid is lateral. Orient these with the proximal head and dorsal distal landmarks before assigning side.

Orient the tibia with its plateau superior, tibial tuberosity and crest anterior, and medial malleolus medial. In anterior view, with the anterior crest facing the observer, a malleolus on the observer’s right indicates a right tibia. A rule that first points the medial malleolus toward the observer does not define an adequate anatomical view.

Anterior views of a left radius and left tibia, shown at different scales. Illustrative orientation. Distal projections on different elements are not interchangeable siding landmarks.

For a typical rib, the head articulates posteriorly toward the vertebral column and the shaft curves anterolaterally around the thorax. The costal groove lies along the inferior internal border. These relationships assist siding when sufficiently preserved; atypical ribs and incomplete fragments require separate assessment.

Use rib-end morphology, curvature and the inferior internal groove together. The first rib differs from typical ribs: it is flattened and its superior scalene tubercle provides an orientation landmark. No universal ribs 1–6 versus 7–12 reliability ranking is established here.

Internal oblique view of a typical left rib. Illustrative anatomy. Rib siding depends on the preserved three-dimensional relationship of several features.

Fragment Identification: Element and Region Assignment

Assess whether the material is osseous, its likely taxonomic origin and the anatomical structures preserved. Antler is bone, not a non-bone alternative. Element, region and side assessments may remain qualified when features are insufficient.

Cortical and trabecular architecture can help recognise osseous material. Osteons are concentric vascular structures, whereas plexiform architecture is not a set of concentric rings. Antler is bony tissue and can contain compact and cancellous regions; it is not excluded merely by finding a cortex and spongy core.

Cortical thickness and internal architecture can help assess a fragment’s anatomical region, but vary with element, sampling location, age and individual. Fixed femoral and rib wall-thickness bands or cavity proportions are not universal diagnostic boundaries.

Cranial vault bone has an outer table, a diploic cancellous layer, and an inner table, a sandwich structure immediately distinguishable in cross-section from long-bone cortex. Vertebral body cortex is very thin over a primarily trabecular interior. These thickness patterns allow assignment to an element class from even a small fragment with a visible cross-section.

Illustrative structural clues. Thickness and layered architecture support anatomical comparison but do not by themselves prove species.

For a fragment, first document the surfaces and structures actually preserved. Compare articular form, attachment sites, curvature and internal architecture with appropriate reference specimens or images. Match corresponding regions and orientation rather than relying on an isolated resemblance.

Preserved joint surfaces and attachment landmarks can be highly informative. Cross-sectional shape, cortex and trabecular structure can add evidence. Their usefulness depends on what survives; no fixed priority order guarantees element identification.

If identification remains uncertain, preserve the fragment’s record and consider further comparison, imaging or suitable laboratory testing. Examination choices should follow the specimen’s condition and the investigative question; destructive testing requires particular care.

In a hypothetical commingled assemblage, element and side inventory can organise later reassociation, while morphology alone may leave some fragments unresolved. Appropriate DNA profiling can assist fragment reassociation where recoverable DNA and suitable comparisons are available. Osteological compatibility is supporting evidence and does not by itself confirm individual identity.

Illustrative counting example, not case evidence. Three non-duplicating left femoral regions require at least three individuals; refitting fragments do not add an individual.

Human versus Non-Human Bone: The Macroscopic Criteria

Assessing human origin is important to medicolegal significance, but uncertainty does not automatically bar investigation or every legal action. Preserve the evidence, state the uncertainty and select appropriate further examination.

Non-human remains can be encountered in many settings, including butchered material, animal burials and scavenged surface scatters. Recovery context helps identify plausible comparisons, but it does not replace examination of the specimen.

Macroscopic criteria for human versus non-human discrimination operate across four domains: overall size and proportion, cortical bone architecture, articular surface morphology, and specific anatomical features that are human-unique.

Size and proportion: the human femoral shaft has a midshaft cross-section that is roughly oval with a mediolaterally flattened shape in the proximal third (platymeria) and more circular in the midshaft.

Shaft size can help comparison but overlaps among species and age groups. A 25–35 mm or 40 mm threshold and a cortical ratio do not independently establish human versus non-human origin.

Cortical proportions vary with species, element, age and loading. There is no universal human cortical-index cutoff of 0.35 or general domestication rule that separates human and domestic animal cortex.

Some avian bones are thin-walled and pneumatic, but not all bird bones share that structure. Human cortical thickness also varies. A sub-millimetre wall or internal strut is not alone a species diagnosis.

Extensive fibrolamellar plexiform architecture is strong evidence of non-human origin in an appropriate adult-sized fragment. It requires correct recognition; simple pale–dark banding is not enough, and absence of plexiform tissue does not confirm human origin.

The full histological basis for this distinction is explained in the bone biology and Haversian baseline topic. Extensive plexiform tissue can support non-human origin when properly recognised, but it is not a blanket courtroom guarantee. Haversian tissue also occurs in non-human species, so absence of plexiform tissue is inconclusive.

Articular surface morphology: the shape and proportions of articular surfaces are highly element-specific and species-specific. The glenoid fossa of the human scapula is pear-shaped; the glenoid of a large dog is more circular. The human talus has a characteristic trochlear surface with medial and lateral facets that is highly specific; ungulate tali (deer, pig, bovid) have a deeply grooved trochlear surface adapted for their locomotor pattern. These articular-surface differences are reliably discriminating when the articular surface is preserved.

A cranial vault can show outer and inner compact tables with intervening diploë. This structure is not human-exclusive: non-human skulls can also contain diploë. Layering and a fixed total-thickness band are insufficient for species identification.

Combine cranial morphology, proportions and suitable comparative material. A layered fragment is not virtually diagnostic of human origin, even when no zoo or primate context is suspected.

Osteon Morphology and Histological Discrimination

Thin-section histology may help when gross morphology is insufficient, but it can be destructive and does not always resolve taxonomic origin. Select an appropriate preparation and comparison method, preserve documentation and report indeterminate results where necessary.

Human secondary osteons can appear approximately circular in transverse section, but size and shape vary with sampling plane, skeletal region and remodelling. Their distributions overlap those of non-human species; one diameter band is not a universal identification threshold.

The lamellar structure (the concentric rings of collagen around the Haversian canal) is visible under polarised light as alternating bright and dark rings. The cement line (the boundary between the osteon and the surrounding interstitial bone) is smooth to slightly scalloped. Secondary osteons (those that have replaced earlier bone) have scalloped cement lines and slightly smaller diameters than primary osteons.

Non-human cortical bone may include plexiform tissue, osteon banding or Haversian remodelling. Deer and bovid osteons are not universally elliptical, and remodelling can remove primary architecture. Pig and other species can overlap human histological features.

Pig bone can overlap human histology. Its use as a research analogue does not make it interchangeable with human material or establish a universal species-confidence ranking. Assess the observed tissue pattern against the comparison method’s actual validation.

Dog and bird cortical microstructure also varies among elements, individuals and species. Do not diagnose taxonomic origin from one supposed universal osteon size or shape; compare the complete tissue pattern using an appropriate method.

Histological age methods assess tissue-specific remodelling observations. Stout and Paine’s 1992 method used ribs and clavicles, not a “short-bone” category or a universal long-bone protocol. Apply the original site and criteria required by the selected method to estimate age at death.

Histological age precision depends on the selected method, tissue, reference sample and application. No single 20–60 year window or±10–12 year 95 per cent interval describes all osteon-counting methods.

Histological age methods may contribute when suitable tissue survives, including when other indicators are missing. Select the method for the anatomical sample and preparation available; preservation and the reference model affect which conclusions remain supportable.

Scroll horizontally if needed to see the full table.

FeatureHumanDeer / bovidPigBird
Osteon shape (histology)Variable; roughly circular profiles may occurVariable; Haversian remodelling can overlap humanCan overlap human featuresVaries by species and sampled tissue
Plexiform boneTypical extensive plexiform tissue is not expectedMay be prominent; assess tissue and remodellingMay include primary fibrolamellar architectureVariable; not diagnosed by cortex thickness alone
Cortical wall thicknessVaries by element, age and sampled siteVariable; overlaps other speciesVariable; no universal 5–8 mm thresholdOften thin, but no universal 1 mm cutoff
Medullary cavityOpen cylinder; cancellous metaphysesOpen cylinder; similar patternOpen cylinderPneumatic (hollow with internal struts in many species)
Cranial vault layersThree layers: outer table, diploe, inner tableDiploë may occur; layering is not human-exclusiveThin diploe in domestic pigNo diploe; thin plate
Interpretive limitationsCombine features and report uncertaintyExtensive plexiform tissue can be informativeHistology may remain inconclusivePneumatic structure alone is not definitive

Foetal Bone Identification: Ribs, Vertebral Arches and Ambiguous Fragments

Foetal and perinatal bone fragments present a specific fragment-identification challenge. In cases of alleged infanticide, neonatal death, or the discovery of buried or concealed neonatal remains, the analyst may receive small, fragile, and poorly preserved bone fragments that must be identified as specifically as possible.

The most common ambiguity in foetal skeletal identification involves rib fragments versus vertebral neural arch pieces. Both are thin, curved, and similarly sized in foetal and perinatal specimens.

The distinguishing features are as follows: rib fragments have a consistent curvature in two planes (the rib curves in the transverse and the sagittal plane simultaneously), a smooth external convex surface, an internal surface with a costal groove along the inferior border (visible with a hand lens), and a cortex that, in cross-section, is plano-convex.

A developing neural-arch portion may preserve pedicle, laminar or articular anatomy. It does not possess a universal pair of “periosteal and articular cortical surfaces,” nor is greater density than a rib a reliable general identifier. Assess multiple preserved features and developmental reference material.

Long-bone diaphyseal fragments in foetal remains are typically thin-walled and cylindrical, with a smooth periosteal surface and a proportionally wide medullary canal relative to the thin cortex. These are distinguishable from rib fragments by their circular cross-section. Skull fragments in foetal remains are incompletely ossified and often show the granular woven bone texture of intramembranous ossification at the margins, with a thin and single-layered table (the three-table diploe structure does not develop until childhood).

Small developing elements can be fragile and poorly preserved. Record possible residues and context, but a calcium-phosphate stain alone cannot be identified as a foetal bone or used to establish that a foetus was present.

  1. Step 1: Is it bone?
    Examine preserved structure using appropriate magnification and comparisons. Antler is bone and may show compact and cancellous architecture; do not classify it as non-osseous solely because it is antler.
  2. Step 2: Is it human?
    Assess anatomy, proportions, architecture and preservation together. Extensive plexiform tissue may support non-human origin, but cortex thickness, absence of plexiform tissue or internal struts alone do not establish species.
  3. Step 3: Histological section if macroscopic is inconclusive
    Consider histology when justified and document any destructive sampling. Assess the full tissue pattern with suitable references; universal osteon shape or diameter rules cannot resolve every human-versus-non-human comparison.
  4. Step 4: Element identification from preserved landmarks
    Articular surface: element-specific. Muscle attachment sites: element-specific. Cross-sectional shape at defined shaft positions: oval vs circular vs plano-convex. Cortical thickness ratios: thick-walled (femur) vs thin-walled (rib) vs sandwich (cranium). Assign to element class; record confidence level.
  5. Step 5: Side determination from asymmetric features
    Apply the element-specific siding criteria. For the clavicle: conoid tubercle and costal tuberosity are inferior surface landmarks; sternal end is pyramidal. For the femur: linea aspera is posterior, head is medially directed, medial condyle is longer. For the os coxae: hold with crest superior; acetabulum faces laterally; pubic symphysis medial and anterior.
  6. Step 6: Age (adult vs sub-adult) and minimum number of individuals
    Assess developmental stage and incompatibility using supported features. An epiphyseal scar alone does not establish subadult status, and density alone does not establish old age. For MNI, count duplicated anatomy after reassociation; multiple fragments from one bone do not automatically increase the minimum.

Radiographic and Case-Level Backstops

Radiography can reveal internal anatomy, and appropriate molecular methods can assist taxonomic assessment. Geometric morphometric comparison requires suitable landmarks and references. FORDISC’s conventional linear craniometrics should not be described as a generic geometric-morphometric species-identification pipeline.

Plain radiography of a fragment reveals internal architecture that may not be visible on the surface: the trabecular pattern of cancellous bone, the thickness profile of the cortex across the full diameter, any pathological changes (lytic lesions, sclerosis, periosteal reactions), and the presence of any residual growth plate or epiphyseal scar.

Radiographic comparison may reveal cortex, trabecular structure or developing centres not exposed externally. Compare equivalent anatomical regions and account for projection and preservation. A reference image supports interpretation only when it is appropriate to the specimen and question.

In a hypothetical search recovery, a curved fragment has insufficient exposed anatomy for a confident human-versus-non-human assessment. The examiner records its location and appearance, protects it from further damage and retains the uncertainty.

Further comparative examination or imaging may reveal diagnostic structures. If it does not, an indeterminate conclusion is appropriate while suitable additional tests are considered. A qualified field assessment should not be converted into a definitive laboratory result.

Validated molecular assays can support species assessment, but human-targeted STR kits are not infallible species tests. Non-human primates and, under some conditions, other non-human DNA can produce amplification; failed amplification also does not prove non-human origin.

A partial human-like profile may reflect contamination, mixed material or cross-reactivity and does not automatically establish the origin of the bone itself. Mitochondrial analysis can help degraded samples when sufficient DNA survives, with appropriate controls and reference comparisons.

For molecular assessment, establish the receiving laboratory’s validated assay, sample requirements and reporting scope. Species assessment and personal identification are different questions. Contamination, cross-reactivity and poor preservation can limit interpretation even when amplification occurs.

Referral statistics describe the specimens selected for a particular service. They cannot substitute for the evidence in an individual fragment. If background frequencies contribute to an interpretation, identify their source, sampling context and relevance.

Appropriate morphological assessment can help target later testing, but there is no universal requirement to perform destructive histology before DNA. Select examinations according to the specimen, preservation and question.

Key terms
Side determination
The osteological process of assigning a paired skeletal element (clavicle, humerus, femur, rib, os coxae, etc.) to the left or right side of the body using asymmetric morphological features that differ between the two sides. Critical for skeletal inventory and minimum-number-of-individuals calculations.
Fragment identification
The assignment of a bone fragment to a specific skeletal element (rib, long-bone shaft, vertebral arch, cranial vault, etc.) and anatomical region, using preserved articular surfaces, muscle attachment sites, cortical thickness ratios, and cross-sectional shape.
Plexiform bone
A fibrolamellar arrangement often seen extensively in non-human mammalian cortex. Correct recognition can support non-human origin, but simple banding is insufficient and its absence does not confirm human origin.
Osteon
An osteonal unit contains concentric lamellae around a vascular canal. Secondary osteons record remodelling; size and shape vary and overlap among species, so a 200–300µmband is not a universal human identifier.
Fragment-identification approach
Assessment of preserved articular form, attachment landmarks, cross-sectional shape and internal architecture to identify a skeletal element or region. Suitable comparative material and adequate preservation are required; some fragments remain indeterminate.
Cortical index
The ratio of total cortical bone area to total bone cross-sectional area at a defined midshaft location. Used in fragment identification to distinguish thick-walled long-bone shafts from thin-walled ribs and from avian or other non-human elements. Also used in osteoporosis assessment in clinical contexts.
Neural arch
The posterior bony arch of a vertebra, formed by two pedicles and two laminae meeting at the spinous process. In foetal and neonatal skeletons, the neural arch is unfused to the vertebral body and is a common source of fragment-identification ambiguity when it resembles a rib piece.
Haversian canal
The central vascular channel of an osteon, carrying blood vessels and nerves through the cortical bone. Diameter 20-70 µm in human bone. Visible in thin-section histology; its population density and surrounding lamellar pattern are used for human-vs-non-human discrimination and histological age estimation.
Minimum number of individuals (MNI)
The smallest number supported by the represented anatomy and incompatibilities after reassociation. Element-and-side duplication is useful, but MNI is not the actual total number of people or a count of loose fragments.
Species confirmation (DNA)
A validated molecular assessment of taxonomic origin using appropriate controls and comparisons. It is distinct from personal identification; a partial human-targeted STR result or failure to amplify is not automatically definitive.

Loading questions…

Test yourself on Forensic Anthropology with free, timed mocks.

Practice Forensic Anthropology questions

Found this useful? Pass it along.