Skip to content

New Study Finds Gaps in Forensic Toxicology Bias Training

New international survey reveals gaps in cognitive-bias training and laboratory policies among forensic toxicology professionals across 43 countries.

By 3 min read

A new international study has identified gaps in cognitive-bias training and laboratory procedures among forensic toxicology professionals, raising questions about how laboratories manage human factors that could influence scientific interpretation.

Published online on 13 November 2026 in the Journal of Analytical Toxicology, the research was conducted by Hilary J. Hamnett of the University of Lincoln, United Kingdom.

Forensic toxicologists examine biological samples to detect and interpret drugs, alcohol, poisons and other substances relevant to criminal investigations and death examinations. Their conclusions can influence investigative decisions and legal proceedings.

However, scientific interpretation is not completely independent of human judgment. Cognitive bias and contextual information can sometimes influence how experts evaluate evidence, particularly when results are uncertain or require interpretation.

To investigate awareness of these issues, the researcher conducted an exploratory online survey involving participants attending the 62nd conference of The International Association of Forensic Toxicologists (TIAFT).

The conference took place in Auckland, New Zealand, from 23 to 27 November 2025.

A total of 51 forensic toxicology professionals from 43 countries voluntarily participated. Their professional experience ranged from one to 50 years.

The survey examined participants' familiarity with cognitive bias, previous training, laboratory policies and the use of procedures intended to reduce potential bias.

The findings revealed that more than three-quarters of respondents were familiar with human factors and cognitive bias.

However, only slightly more than half reported receiving training on the subject.

Laboratory policies addressing cognitive bias were also uncommon. Approximately one-third of participants reported that their workplaces had such policies.

Similarly, procedures specifically intended to minimise bias in forensic toxicology were reportedly used in only around one-third of respondents' laboratories.

These findings suggest that awareness of cognitive bias does not necessarily translate into formal training or established laboratory procedures.

Forensic laboratories may consider measures such as managing exposure to potentially irrelevant contextual information, documenting interpretive decisions and incorporating human-factor considerations into quality assurance systems.

However, the study did not experimentally measure whether cognitive bias affected the accuracy of participants' forensic conclusions.

The findings also require caution because the survey involved a relatively small, voluntary group of conference attendees. Their responses cannot establish how frequently bias-management procedures are used across all forensic toxicology laboratories worldwide.

Nevertheless, the research highlights an important issue in forensic quality management: reliable analytical instruments alone cannot eliminate the possibility of human influences on evidence interpretation.

The study encourages further research and the development of profession-specific guidance to help forensic toxicology laboratories recognise and manage potential sources of bias.